Skip to content

Asr Time Calculation: Hanafi vs Shafi'i

The difference in Asr times arises from different juristic methods: the Shafi'i, Maliki, and Hanbali schools start Asr when an object's shadow equals its height (1x shadow), while the Hanafi school starts Asr when the shadow is twice the object's height (2x shadow). (updated )

The Shadow-Length Rules Explained

The start of Asr Salah is defined by the length of an object's shadow compared to the object itself, adjusted for the shadow length at solar noon (when the sun is at its highest point).

Shafi'i, Maliki, Hanbali Method (Standard / 1x Shadow):

Asr starts when the shadow of an object equals its height plus the shadow length at solar noon.

Hanafi Method (2x Shadow):

Asr starts when the shadow of an object equals twice its height plus the shadow length at solar noon.

Because the Hanafi method requires the sun to descend further, the Hanafi Asr time starts significantly later than the Shafi'i standard method—typically by 30 to 60 minutes depending on the location and season.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do prayer apps show two different Asr times?
Prayer apps show two times because they implement different juristic criteria (fiqh) for the beginning of Asr. The standard method (Shafi'i, Maliki, Hanbali) triggers earlier at a shadow ratio of 1:1, whereas the Hanafi method triggers later at a shadow ratio of 2:1.
Which calculation method does LivePrayerTime use?
LivePrayerTime adapts to regional defaults to remain consistent with local practices. In India and surrounding South Asian regions, we default to the Hanafi method using the University of Islamic Sciences, Karachi parameters. In Indonesia, we default to the Kemenag parameters which utilize the Shafi'i juristic method for Asr.
Is it permissible to pray Asr at the Shafi'i time if I follow the Hanafi school?
Generally, Hanafis pray Asr at the Hanafi (2x shadow) time. However, in regions where congregation (Jamaat) is established according to the Shafi'i time, some jurists allow Hanafis to join the congregation to preserve the reward of praying in congregation. You should consult a local scholar for specific juristic guidance.